Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Margaret Redus's avatar

💙💙💙

James R. Carey's avatar

Does the “I would never let myself get fooled” sentiment demonstrate a lack of understanding of the methods used by cults and domestic abusers? The “yes” answer is itself a testable assumption.

I’m not questioning the reality that people expressing that sentiment become victims of psychological manipulation, but not everyone subjected to those tactics becomes a victim. Is that just random luck? Is it a function of the manipulator’s skill? Or is it what I suspect: that it’s like COVID where the likelihood that an individual will test positive is a function of whether the individual has been immunized.

Australian Nobel laureate Barry Marshall said that trying to convince other clinicians of his research — overturning established medical dogma and revolutionizing the treatment of peptic ulcers — was “impossible.” With that word, he described a scientific community responding to readily observable evidence the way I respond to mosquitos landing on my forearm. Ref: https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(05)67587-3/fulltext

Albert Einstein said, “I have no special talent. I am only patiently curious.” In those words, he described a habitual response very different than the response Marshall received, not to mention the response a concerned individual receives from a victim of a cult’s psychological manipulation. And Einstein was also describing how he practiced science.

In his 1926 book, The Story of Philosophy, Will Durant summed up the work of Aristotle (384-322 BC) by saying: “We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, then, is not an act, but a habit.” Einstein’s excellence, then, was not an act, but a good habit. Conversely, the response Marshall received was not an act, but a bad habit.

Hypothetically, it’s possible to distinguish between the Einstein behavior pattern and the “reflexive dismissal of irrefutable evidence” behavior pattern, and it’s also possible to correlate that with the probability that an individual is susceptible to a cult’s recruitment tactics and/or domestic violence.

I don’t know if running such an experiment would be possible, but I suggest Einstein would have been quickly assessed by a cult as immune from the recruitment effort.

No posts

Ready for more?